aba events

    Photo Quiz Hints


    I’ve now heard from a variety of folks who have opinions about the identities of the birds depicted in the New Photo Quiz on p. 80 of the May 2011 issue of Birding.

    Let’s take a look!

    First things first. The images below are high-resolution jpegs of the three quiz photos. As I understand it, jpegs look better, all else being equal, on computer monitors than on paper. The images below may differ in subtle but important ways from what you see in your print copy of the May 2011 Birding. And there’s one big difference: You can click on the images below and view them at much higher resolution than is possible on the printed page—until such time as we start publishing Birding on 24"-by-36" paper. I wouldn’t hold your breath on that one.


    Here’s Quiz Bird A, a black bird with its bill open. As with all three of the quiz images reproduced here, you can click on this image to make it a lot bigger. Comment: For Quiz Bird A, enlarging the image probably doesn’t add much to the identification process. Question: If you’re positive about this bird’s identity, then what’s the deal with its tail? Hint: If you’re struggling with this bird’s identity, check out its bill, its eye, and, well, its tail.

    11-4-12-F01 [Mystery Bird A]Quiz Bird A—May 2011 Birding Photo Quiz. Click on image to enlarge…keeping in mind that jpegs can look different on the computer monitor vs. on the printed page.


    And here’s Quiz Bird B, a black bird on a rock. Two hints on this one. First, enlarging this image might actually be construed as a detriment to the identification process. In one sense, I’m being facetious: When it comes to identifying birds correctly, you can never have too much information. In another sense, I’m being serious: There’s a well-known psychological/perceptual effect of seeing an image larger than life. In an ornithological context, I’ve seen this effect demonstrated with hummingbird photos; in a nutshell, we identify (or misidentify) hummingbirds, in part, on the actual, literal size of the image we’re looking at. And here’s the second hint: Check out the apparent relative lengths of the bird’s tail and wings. I think that second hint is going to help some folks a lot, but I think it’s also going to mess up other people. It’s all about psychology and perception!

    11-4-12-F02 [Mystery Bird B]Quiz Bird B—May 2011 Birding Photo Quiz. Click on image to enlarge…but be aware of the psychological and perceptual effects of doing so!


    Finally, here’s Quiz Bird C, a blackish bird in flight. Answers to this one have been all over the place, and that’s often how it is with Birding photo quizzes. And here’s something else: Folks’ approaches—in distinction from their actual answers—have likewise been all over the place. Some readers got this one right away, but others agonized over it. Some folks ID’d it—or misID’d it—by “jizz”; others went for good ole fashion “field marks.” Some of you keyed in on feathers and feather tracts; others of you were drawn to the bird’s bare parts and body shape. And y’know what? All of the preceding is good. The best—or, well, the most successful—approach to bird identification is holistic. Good ID skills rely on instinct and knowledge, on details and impression. Oh, and as to a hint, here’s a biggie: Enlarge the photo, and check out the bird’s bill.

    11-4-12-F03 [Mystery Bird C]Quiz Bird C—May 2011 Birding Photo Quiz. Click on image to enlarge…and see whether fine details of the bird’s bill confirm your initial instincts about the bird’s identity.


    So, how did you approach these three quiz photos? Please let us know. That’s why there’s a “Comments” field for each and every post to The ABA Blog. And that’s the whole point of The ABA Blog—to keep the conversation going, among all of us who marvel at and care about wild birds.


    The following two tabs change content below.
    Ted Floyd

    Ted Floyd

    Ted Floyd is the Editor of Birding magazine, and he is broadly involved in other programs and initiatives of the ABA. He is the author of more than 100 magazine and journal articles, and has written four recent books, including an ABA title, the ABA Guide to Birds of Colorado. Floyd is a frequent speaker at birding festivals and state ornithological society meetings, and he has served on the boards of several nonprofit organizations. Mainly, he listens to birds at night.
    Ted Floyd

    Latest posts by Ted Floyd (see all)

    • Mike

      Can’t enlarge the second (middle) photo

    • http://profile.typepad.com/tfloyd Ted Floyd

      Hm… Works over here on my end, Mike. Anybody else out there having a problem with the second (middle) photo? Thanks, –Ted

    • http://abqbirding.wordpress.com Matt

      Yes, the photo is not a link.

    • Marty Mathieson

      I can’t enlarge the 2nd photo either!

    • http://profile.typepad.com/tfloyd Ted Floyd

      Ah. I see the problem now. And I’ve fixed it. Mike, Matt, and Marty: Thanks for bringing this to our attention. Anyhow, that 2nd photo is now clickable/enlargeable.

      So…what do y’all think the quiz birds are??

    • http://www.nabirding.com Greg Neise

      #1 is a Boat-tailed Grackle.

      #2 speaks to me, and it says Fish Crow. The log wings fit…and it’s not a Raven. Plus I see a little bit of throat-shag going on.

      #3 is a dark morph Parasitic Jaeger.

    • http://profile.typepad.com/tfloyd Ted Floyd

      Thanks, Greg. I wish #2 would speak to ME… ;)

      And thanks for explaining how you got to Fish Crow, e.g., long wings.

      I’m curious: How did you arrive at Boat-tailed Grackle and Parasitic Jaeger?

      Thanks again!

    Birders know well that the healthiest, most dynamic choruses contain many different voices. The birding community encompasses a wide variety of interests, talents, and convictions. All are welcome.
    If you like birding, we want to hear from you.
    Read More »

    Recent Comments




    via email

    Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    • Open Mic: Searching for Snowy Owls in Ohio March 25, 2015 5:22
      At the beginning of this year, I remembered missing the chance to spot a Snowy Owl when the bird stormed across the United States the previous winter, so I was determined to see one of these birds this winter. […]
    • Mothing: The Nighttime Addiction March 18, 2015 5:49
      Note: Although this may not seem to be a relevant post on The Eyrie, I thought it would be a good idea to share the obsession that sparked my passion for the natural world as a whole. I hope this post will inform and excite you about moths; perhaps even making them an obsession of […]
    • Book Review: Ten Thousand Birds March 10, 2015 5:36
      Ten Thousand Birds: Ornithology Since Darwin, by Tim Birkhead, Jo Wimpenny, and Bob Montgomerie Princeton University Press, 2014 544 pages, $45.00 hardcover ABA Sales / Buteo Books How did today’s birds come to be? How has the history of ornithology evolved since Darwin’s time. These questions, and many more, are answered comprehensively in the […]

    Follow ABA on Twitter