aba events

The McGurk Effect: Does It Impact Bird Identification?

facebooktwitter

SWWA WV by JAG

Swainson’s Warbler singing near New River Gorge, WV…at least it sounded like a Swainson’s while I was watching it!

This really is an aside, not a full-blown post. But I thought it might kick off some interesting discussion.

I saw this post on Krulwich Wonders (an NPR blog) about the McGurk effect, where the BBC video below quite convincingly demonstrates that your eyes can “overrule” your ears, tricking you into mishearing things.

I wonder how much (or if) this McGurk effect might enter into bird identification? I often have the experience where the sound a bird makes clinches the identification of a bird I can’t see or can’t see very well. But what about a bird that I’ve made a (possibly incorrect) visual ID of? Could I then mis-hear its calls based on my visually-derived assumptions? Should we all close our eyes when listening to birds sing, so as to hear what they are “really” singing?

 

The following two tabs change content below.
Jeff Gordon

Jeff Gordon

Jeff Gordon is the president of the American Birding Association. There's very little about birds, birding, and birders that he doesn't find fascinating, though he's especially interested in birding culture and the many ways we all communicate our passion for birds, including this Blog.
  • http://www.BirdingIsFun.com Robert Mortensen

    Dang! So I can count the birds I hear, but don’t see. And I can count the birds I see, but don’t hear. But I can no longer count the birds that I both see and hear…because what I was hearing, while I was seeing, is impaired by my own brain. What about that Bewick’s Wren I heard singing, but when I saw it, it was a Song Sparrow singing just like a Bewick’s Wren…does that mean it was really a Bewick’s Wren? Oh man, this is turning into birding existentialism.

  • Dianne C.

    Maybe it is onlt triggered by watching critters with lips! Lol.

  • noneW

    So i was listening to this without ANY visuals while I browed another page…. this seems to be more an experiment in suggestion– several of the alleged clear “Bas” are not at all..

    at 40, 46, and 1:17 2:03 , they are “fas”, though they are described to the audience as starting with “B”.

  • Tom

    Do I have to remove my recent sighting of an Ivory-billed Woodpecker from my life list?

  • http://200birds.blogspot.com Ryan O’Donnell

    These aren’t really relevant to birding, but here is whole website devoted to taking advantage of the McGurk Effect in a comedic way:
    http://badlipreading.tumblr.com/

Birders know well that the healthiest, most dynamic choruses contain many different voices. The birding community encompasses a wide variety of interests, talents, and convictions. All are welcome.
If you like birding, we want to hear from you.
Read More »

Recent Comments

  • Ted Floyd, in The Big Night... { Just so that the whole world knows: Bill's photos, appearing in the post above, look much better without my doctoring... :-) }
  • Ted Floyd, in The Big Night... { If anybody can track this down, please let me know. }
  • Mark Stevenson, in The Big Night... { Somewhere way back in an old issue of Birding is an article about a nightbird big day (?night ) in Arizona. }
  • Terry Bronson, in Rare Bird Alert: May 29, 2015... { Amazingly, West Virginia had a second Common Gallinule on May 27 and 28 in Lewis County. }
  • Denis Lepage, in Rare Bird Alert: May 29, 2015... { In the latest summer edition of the QuébecOiseaux magazine, there is a photo of an Apus swift, which appears to be a Common Swift, taken... }
  • Older »

Categories

Authors

Archives

via email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

  • Meet Dessi Sieburth, 2015 ABA Young Birder of the Year May 17, 2015 12:00
    Learn more about Dessi Sieburth, the 12-year-old 2015 Young Birder of the Year! […]
  • Wildlife Ecology Research April 22, 2015 11:35
    Rensselaerville Falls, Huyck Preserve and Biological Research Station. July 13, 2014. What: Wildlife Ecology Research Program for high school students entering their Junior or Senior Year. Where: Huyck Preserve and Biological Research Station 5052 Delaware Turnpike Rensselaerville, NY 12147 When: Late applications due May 1 by 5 PM, EDT. Session I—July 5-26 Session II—August […]
  • Young Birder Blog Birding #37 April 8, 2015 4:19
    For many birders, February is a month of waiting. After February, the snow will melt and the first Killdeers and American Woodcocks will usher in a parade of exciting spring migrants. […]

Follow ABA on Twitter