aba events

    Your turn: What the Heck is a Tanager?

    That’s a question a lot of birders are asking these days. And here’s a hint: “Scarlet”, “Summer”, “Western”, and “Hepatic”, are not the answers.

    In the lead article in the 2013 issue of Birder’s Guide to Listing and Taxonomy, author Alan Knue walks us through the vast assemblage of “nine-primaries oscines”, with the goal of explaining what a tanager is (and what it’s not).

    It’s a colorful journey that–in the ABA Area, at least–ends at a not-so-colorful destination. But you’ll have to read the article to find out where that is! To read the article, and the entire issue online, just click here.

    Alan and I both invite you to share your comments, questions, and elucidations below.

    What the Heck is a Tanager?

    The following two tabs change content below.
    Michael Retter
    Michael L. P. Retter is the editor of the ABA's newest magazine, Birder's Guide. He also wears his ABA cap while working as a Technical Reviewer for Birding magazine. When not at home, Michael is often leading tours in Middle America (Mexico through Panama). He currently lives with his fiancé, Matt, in Fort Worth, Texas. In his fleeting free time there, he pursues interests in horticulture (especially orchids), music, cooking, and numismatics. Michael also runs GBNA, the continent's informal club and email list for LGBT birders.
    Michael Retter

    Latest posts by Michael Retter (see all)

    • AJ Knue

      I received a nice email from Kevin Burns (whose work can be
      found at http://kevinburnslab.com/). He
      is one of the authors of the Barker et al. paper cited and has been working on
      tanagers and the question “what is a tanager?” for over 20 years. He

      “It’s exciting to finally be at a point where we can figure
      this out….Even though we can finally say what belongs with the tanagers, there
      still isn’t any single morphological character that defines the group well. However,
      I argue that it’s precisely that reason that the group is so interesting to
      study from an evolutionary perspective. It allows us to look at the evolution
      of diverse bill types, coloration, ecological niche, etc and we are now looking
      at all these characters on the phylogeny.

      From the work in my lab, we now have 371 species in
      tanagers, making it the second largest avian family (after the Tyrannidae) and
      roughly 10% of all songbirds. I’m hoping now that the group is better defined,
      it might become as well known and as well studied as some smaller families of
      birds. I suppose I’m more optimistic than the way your article ends, I do think
      we have answered the question “what is a tanager” with confidence.
      Having worked on this group for a long time and seeing all the different types
      of genetic analyses that have been used over the years and those that are now
      available and on the horizon, I don’t think there will be any major changes
      beyond what the Barker et al. study show. I should also say that I have another
      paper, currently in review, that samples molecular data from 95% of those 371
      species. Our results are congruent with Barker et al. and we have more detail
      on the tanager phylogeny itself. Regarding which tanagers are in the ABA area.
      You’re right White-collared Seedeater is definitely a tanager. Spindalis is
      not, as you say. Regarding the dome-nesters (Bananaquit, Tiaris olivaceus, and
      T. bicolor) those are definitely tanagers. We pretty clearly showed this in a
      paper in 2012 in Evolution. But really, it was work done in the 1990’s using
      DNA hybridization by Bledsoe as well as Sibley that were the first to show
      this. The South American Classification committee finally switched them over to
      tanagers, I have no idea why the AOU still has Coereba in insertae cedis. There
      is nothing uncertain about its placement.”

      I agree with his statement that we in fact do have a good
      idea of what a tanager is- with the movement of several groups from the
      Emberizidae (like the seedeaters, grassquits, bananaquit) and Cardinalidae
      (including the Neotropical saltators) to the Thraupidae, as well as the
      movement of several others out (like the Chlorospingus/ Bush Tanagers to the
      Emberizidae), the Thraupidae are much better defined that it has been in years.

      Regarding the dome nest builders that Kevin mentions above,
      the South American Checklist Committee (SACC) moved this group into the
      Thraupidae in February 2012 (see Proposal #512 http://www.museum.lsu.edu/~Remsen/SACCprop512.html).
      The AOU North American Checklist Committee will likely also adopt this change
      at some point in the future, but even without the official sanction of the
      NACC, it appears the Bananaquit and Grassquits clearly belong in the Tanagers.

    Birders know well that the healthiest, most dynamic choruses contain many different voices. The birding community encompasses a wide variety of interests, talents, and convictions. All are welcome.
    If you like birding, we want to hear from you.
    Read More »

    Recent Comments




    Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    • Cape May Youth Autumn Birding Day 2014 February 5, 2015 7:05
      The Cape May Autumn Birding Festival is a weekend long event that is in its 68th year now, making it the longest-running birding festival in North America. […]
    • Young Birder Blog Birding #36 December 30, 2014 6:50
      As the year winds down, many of us are enjoying or preparing for Christmas Bird Counts! […]
    • Open Mic: Birds of the Black Forest Fire December 23, 2014 7:01
      When I took on the challenge of the 2014 Young Birder of the Year Contest, I was fully aware that it would be the hardest thing I had ever done. I planned to devote myself to the study of birds for nearly six months spending hours each day compiling a field notebook, studying nest boxes, […]

    Follow ABA on Twitter