aba events
Nikon Monarch 7

    Juncos and Science

    A review by Rick Wright

    Ordinary Extraordinary Junco, by Jonathan Atwell, Steve Burns, and Ellen Ketterson

    Junco Project, 2013

    $5.00–DVD, 1:30

    Available for purchase or free download

    Look outside.

    It is winter as I write, and over much of the ABA Area—and well south into Middle America, too—there’s a good chance that your eye will come to rest on a member of one of the most familiar of all American sparrow genera, the juncos.

    Familiar, yes, and in most of their range most of the time, abundant, easily outnumbering all the other birds combined at my snowy feeders. But there is still a lot to learn about, and from, the juncos—dark-eyed and yellow-eyed, gray-headed and pink-sided, Baird’s and Ridgway’s and Shufeldt’s, that whole gloriously gray lot. Some of the mysteries are revealed in an utterly fascinating new film about these feathered “rock stars.”

    Screenshot 2014-01-10 09.42.51Every birder, even those of us with regular access to only a single junco “kind,” will have noticed how variable these tame sparrows can be. The juncos of my New Jersey backyard, all of them presumably “just” Slate-colored Juncos of the subspecies hyemalis, show an astonishing range of plumages, from the slatiest of blackish (apparent) males to the warmest, softest of pastel-brown (apparent) females; occasionally a bird pops in with white wing bars or a hint of a white eye ring. All that pales, of course, when compared to the variability exhibited by juncos in the Midwest, West, and Mexico, where the birder might be forgiven for seriously wondering—just as scientific ornithology continues to seriously wonder—just how many species we’re dealing with.

    That physical variability is accompanied by a similar plasticity in behavior, sure signs that the juncos are especially quick to evolve in response to changing environments, and making of them ideal subjects for the investigation of speciation, physiology, and animal behavior.

    BINbuttonOrdinary Extraordinary Junco begins with the account of such an experiment from nearly 100 years ago, when William Rowan, a Canadian zoologist of cosmopolitan background and training, began a study of captive juncos that would demonstrate, for the first time, the role of photoperiod in triggering physiological changes necessary to the birds’ migration and breeding behavior. This is a fascinating and too little-known story, combining science with institutional and disciplinary history; the fact that it is told on screen by actors in period costume detracts only slightly from its significance.

    The ninety-minute video is divided into six chapters, each of which can be profitably watched on its own. That is not to say, however, that the sections are unrelated or that their sequence is unmotivated. The account of Rowan’s spare experiment on the cold plains of Alberta is followed immediately by a detailed report of the elaborate studies being carried out in the mountains of Virginia by a team led by Ellen Ketterson of the University of Indiana.

    Working with both captive and color-marked wild juncos over some thirteen years, Ketterson and her students and colleagues have deepened our understanding of the complex role played by hormones in  social and parental behavior. By experimentally manipulating testosterone levels in male Slate-colored Juncos, the Indiana scientists have determined that those with higher levels sing more frequently, hold larger territories, and (thanks to an increased frequency of extra-pair copulation) produce more young. Those same males, however, also devote less parental care to their young, and themselves survive at a lower rate than juncos with normal levels of testosterone. These are findings whose significance goes far beyond a single species.

    The film’s central chapters address issues of evolution and speciation. Lovely video sequences showing breeding Pink-sided, Oregon, Gray-headed, and White-winged Juncos, along with the widely disparate habitats each occupies, introduce fundamental questions about the origins and complex relationships of these diverse populations, most neatly summed up by the footage of a mixed pair—a male Gray-headed and a female Oregon junco—in dutiful attendance on their hale and hearty nestlings.

    After a brief summary of Alden Miller’s work in the 1930s and 1940s (I would have been happy to hear Jonathan Dwight’s name mentioned in passing, too), Borja Milá of the National Museum in Madrid explains, clearly and cogently, how techniques for genetic analysis not available to earlier researchers now make it possible to reconstruct the evolutionary history of the juncos. Study of mitochondrial DNA has revealed that the ancestral junco was a yellow-eyed bird. That ancestor moved north with the receding glaciers less than 20,000 years ago, and rapidly diversified into the dark-eyed juncos we know today from northern North America, which, given their very recent and very rapid divergence, still differ only slightly from one another genetically.

    The film also offers a salutary and fascinating reminder that juncos are more than just the well-known dooryard snowbirds. The yellow-eyed juncos turn out to be much more distantly related to one another than are their various dark-eyed congeners among themselves. The soft-colored Baird’s Junco of Baja California, the olive-toned and relatively dark-tailed Guatemala Junco, and the “standard” Yellow-eyed Junco of the Mexican highlands and southwestern US appear to have gone their separate evolutionary ways half a million years ago, rather than the scant 10,000 marking the start of differentiation among the various dark-eyed populations. The research described in the film indicates that these three, wholly allopatric groups of “the” Yellow-eyed Junco are in fact best considered distinct species—a fact of considerable importance to nascent conservation efforts in the small, remote ranges occupied by the Baird’s and Guatemala Juncos.

    The rarest, most isolated, and most little-known of all the juncos is a dark-eyed group, surviving as a population of just a few hundred birds on Mexico’s Guadalupe Island, 150 miles from the coast of Baja California. Introduced livestock devastated Guadalupe’s forests and drove several of its 40 endemic plants and animals into extinction before the last goats were finally removed in 2007. The junco—brown, dull-backed, and strikingly long-billed—is once again reproducing successfully, but its population growth is, obviously, strictly limited by the extent of its habitat, today no more than 300 acres of dry cypress forest. Perhaps surprisingly, genetic analysis shows that the dark-eyed Guadalupe Junco is most closely related to the yellow-eyed Guatemala Junco; it is, nevertheless, sufficiently distinct genetically that Ketterson and Milá consider it, too, a separate species.

    The final chapter in the film returns the viewer north of the border, to a university campus in San Diego, where Oregon Juncos of the subspecies thurberi established a breeding outpost in the early 1980s. Now totaling about 80 pairs, this isolated urban population has already diverged measurably from its mountain-breeding relatives in behavior, voice, and physical characteristics, providing an impressive window into evolution in “real time.” Thus, for example, the lowland colonists commence breeding earlier than their montane ancestors, and now produce up to four broods a year; the males have evolved to be less aggressive and more heavily invested in care of the young. In adapting to their bustling urban environment, the juncos have lost the shyness of mountain birds, approaching humans more closely and more readily exploring new situations. These novel traits, from shorter wings to lower stress hormone levels, have evolved with startling rapidity, over less than a single human generation.

    We are approaching the centennial of the first serious attempt to come to terms with the genus Junco in all its bewildering complexity. Little could Jonathan Dwight have imagined in 1918, or even William Rowan in 1924, how much there still is to learn today from a bird that is, indeed, both so ordinary and so very remarkable.

    Rick Wright Dece 2013

    - Rick Wright is the Book Review Editor at Birding and the ABA Blog. His forthcoming publications include the ABA Field Guide to Birds of New Jersey and the sparrows volume in the Peterson Reference Guide series.

    Recommended citation:

    Wright, R. 2014. Juncos and Science [a review of Ordinary Extraordinary Junco, by Jonathan Atwell, Steve Burns, and Ellen Ketterson]. Birding 46.1: 75.

    The following two tabs change content below.
    Birding Book Reviews

    Birding Book Reviews

    Birding Book Reviews publishes Birding magazine's reviews on line. Book reviews are edited by Rick Wright.
    Birding Book Reviews

    Latest posts by Birding Book Reviews (see all)

    • Rick Wright

      Here, hot off the presses, is a proposal that the AOU n o t accept the evidence for the specific distinctness of the Guadalupe Junco: http://www.aou.org/committees/nacc/proposals/2014-A.pdf

      • Jonathan Atwell

        Thanks Rick, for calling this recent issue of AOU Classification Committee proposals to our attention. I hope any interested parties and individuals take a close look at the AOU proposal you linked (page 23 for the junco) AND the published research indicating the degree to which Guadalupe Juncos are morphologically, behaviorally (song), and genetically distinct (I linked the article below)! I am personally not an expert in phylogenetics or systematics per se, but my interpretation is that the available data support clear morphological differentiation and old (600,000+years) genetic differentiation, with very limited subsequent gene flow–along with at least initial steps towards a mechanism of reproductive isolation (marked song divergence). Here is the link to the Aleixandre, Mila, et al., research article Dr. Rising mentions in his AOU Committee evaluation: http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0063242
        One thing I can say for certain having had the privilege to visit the Guadalupe Island Juncos, is that they are a very small and hence sensitive population inhabiting a tiny and critically endangered fragment of remaining forest/savannah habitat on the once tree-covered island—-so this is an important discussion regarding the future of this unique junco group!

        • Rick Wright

          Thanks, Jonathan. I haven’t read the paper yet, but look forward to it.
          As an addendum to my review, one very important point the film makes is about the close connection between taxonomic understanding and conservation; any small and vulnerable population is, sadly, more likely to receive protection (or at least attention) if it “is something” with a name and a status.

    • Diane Porter

      Thanks. All good stuff to ponder.

    • Ted Floyd

      Antbirds in Costa Rica, spring warblers in Pennsylvania, juncos in the Colorado foothills on snowy mornings in January…such assemblages are the very essence of biodiversity.

      Earlier this month, Joel Such and Marcel Such and I were fortunate to come upon a flock with seven named–and seven distinctive–taxa of juncos: Slate-colored Juncos, Oregon Juncos, Cassiar Juncos, Pink-sided Juncos, Gray-headed Juncos, White-winged Juncos, and Ridgway’s Juncos.

      [Cassiar Junco is the name given to a population that appears intermediate between Slate-colored and Oregon; Ridgway's Junco, I learned recently from Rick Wright, is the name given to the distinctive, stereotyped hybrid of Pink-sided and Gray-headed juncos.]

      The experience was every bit as colorful and thrilling as that of ogling male Setophagas on a balmy May morning in the upper Ohio River valley.

      • Ted Floyd

        Learn more about Pink-sided x Gray-headed Juncos in this 2005 Western Birds paper by Robert A. Hamilton and Peter A. Gaede:

        http://tinyurl.com/WB-Juncos-Hamilton

      • Jonathan Atwell

        Hi Ted–
        as a current junco researcher (and one of the producers of the film Rick reviewed here), I would *love* to know the specific location of that incredible winter flock you observed with the seven different junco forms!!?? I’ve observed flocks with four or five different junco types at once on Mt. Laguna, CA in winter, but never seven! Was this in the Colorado foothills somewhere as you’re post suggests? I’ve heard of similar reports from AZ mtns in winter. A photo of this occurrence would be like gold to us! Alas, I never got one of the Mt. Laguna mixed junco flocks. Best, Jonathan

    • Ted Floyd

      Hey, Rick. Regarding this:

      “The juncos of my New Jersey backyard, all of them presumably ‘just’ Slate-colored Juncos of the subspecies hyemalis…”

      You don’t have some Cassiar (J. h. cismonanus) Juncos in the mix over there in New Jersey?

      Not that I’m trying to open up a can of worms or anything…

      • Rick Wright

        Can o’worms? Of course not!
        I do every once in a while see a bird that strikes me as Cassiar-like among our yard juncos, but what gives me pause (besides an intermittent agnosticism about just what the Cassiar junco _is_) is that every single candidate I’ve identified has been female(-plumaged), making me wonder whether I’m just overreacting to a particularly well-marked slate-colored female drifted down from the Adirondacks.
        I did see the one New Jersey skin (labeled as being) of cismontanus not long ago, and was unimpressed.

    Birders know well that the healthiest, most dynamic choruses contain many different voices. The birding community encompasses a wide variety of interests, talents, and convictions. All are welcome.
    If you like birding, we want to hear from you.
    Read More »

    Recent Comments

    • Anonymous, in Rare Bird Alert: August 29, 2014... { A Canada Warbler found and photographed in Goshen, Wyoming is one of less than 10 reports for the state. }
    • Liron, in The Unlikeliest Twitch... { Fantastic post, so much fun to read (and watch)! Congrats on the successful twitch! }
    • Nick Block, in ABA Checklist Committee Adds Egyptian Goose to ABA Checklist... { Hi Cory, Currently, there are no explicit rules addressing this important question. This question is the next recording-related item on the Recording Standards and Ethics... }
    • chainzaw, in On Stringing...... { Version:1.0 StartHTML:0000000149 EndHTML:0000002566 StartFragment:0000000199 EndFragment:0000002532 StartSelection:0000000199 EndSelection:0000002532 Jeez ... tough crowd here! Yes, we have all known serial stringers. But if you are so compulsive... }
    • John, in The Unlikeliest Twitch... { What a "rip", thanks for sharing such an exciting "twitchy" experience Greg and John! And a big thank you to your benefactor, not everyday someone... }
    • Older »

    Categories

    Authors

    Archives

    Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    • Open Mic: My First Breeding Bird Survey August 12, 2014 8:22
      When I got asked to go on my first Breeding Bird Survey with one of our areas top birders, I jumped at the opportunity! I met Katie Koch, a US Fish and Wildlife Service bird biologist at 4:45am. That was the earliest time I've been birding by 15 minutes. […]
    • What to Do When You Feel Under the Weather at Bird Camp August 6, 2014 6:47
      Imagine you are at a bird camp. Camp Chiricahua, for instance. Maybe this year. Maybe even this week. You are having lots of fun making new friends, seeing lots of cool birds, and traveling to all sorts of awesome places. But with all this activity and excitement, you start wearing yourself down. […]
    • Young Birder Blog Birding #31 August 1, 2014 5:45
      July is often a difficult month for birders, but the month has come to an end. For many birds, breeding season is long gone and preparation for fall migration have begun. […]

    Follow ABA on Twitter

    Nature Blog Network